The Chapmans of Whitby Castle – A Search Begins – Part 1

Whitby Castle - Rye Golf Club - day

Whitby Castle, Rye, New York – Front edifice today (Photo credit Jay Heritage Center)

To find the stories that follow, I’ve buried myself in library stacks all along the East Coast. My eyes have gone glassy for hours fixed on a digital stream of 19th century newspapers and class notes, but most of all obituaries, looking for the tiniest factoids. In death, very often, we bare it all. But as any historian will tell you, no matter how many books or bytes you wade through, when you’re tracing the arc of a person’s life, in due course you come up against the one dead-end that can really help you: a cemetery. Here under towering willow and gnarly oak trees, the simplest or most elaborate monuments offer a poignant context for familial relationships. Who is in the family plot? Who’s not and why? Scanning softened marble tablets for meaningful chisel marks is not that different from deciphering hieroglyphs. Birth dates, marriage dates, death dates – that middle initial or maternal middle name recorded nowhere else in the world – can be found in graveyards, if you’re lucky. If you’re not so lucky, tombstone rubbers, robbers, and acid rain have erased many inscriptions for good.

So a cemetery was definitely on my road trip list to find out more about Rye’s mysterious William P. Chapman, the wealthy stockbroker who built Whitby Castle, a Gothic Revival jewel in the Boston Post Road Historic District. How did it come to be that we know so little about the owner and history of this grand estate? Everyone knew about the home’s famous architect, Alexander Jackson Davis, but no one seemed to know one whit  about the guy who paid his commission and lived in the building from 1854 to the mid 1870s! Where did he come from? Where did he go? What did the P.  stand for? Patient readers will follow my wanderings in this first entry, as I tell you about what I unearthed in my quest.

Whitby Castle

Whitby Castle, Rye, New York – Archival Print showing rear elevation (Photo credit Jay Heritage Center)

To understand William Chapman, it helps to look at his family. In 1825, his father, the Hon. Asa Chapman, a venerated jurist of Connecticut’s Supreme Court died of consumption, “the wasting disease,” what we know today as tuberculosis. He was 56 years old. Judge Chapman was a 6th generation descendant of Robert Chapman of Hull, England, one of the first settlers of “Say-Brooke,” a vast shoreline tract so named for its original English patent holders, the Viscount Saye & Sele and Lord Brooke. According to family history, the “Old Progenitor” first came across the pond in 1635, arriving in Newtown, Massachusetts (today’s Cambridge.) From there he headed down to the mouth of the Connecticut River under orders from Governor John Winthrop to thwart the Dutch from seizing the strategic port first. Together with 25 other men and women, Chapman helped establish a fortified garrison that held its own against repeated assaults by the Pequot Indians before establishing his own 400-500 acre farm on a lot previously cultivated by native tribes.

Robert Chapman’s new homestead had good soil, fresh air and clean water, and it was strolling distance from the shore’s bounty of oysters and the river’s endless stores of salmon and shad. Descendants recalled stands of old pear and apple trees that thrived at the site. But the ground was also “full of shells and arrow-heads, and remains of warriors” which were disturbingly disturbed in several instances, probably as a consequence of the burial of Asa’s own ancestors on the old grounds. In the 17th and 18th century, many of the deceased were buried right where they had lived, sometimes without markers, just as the ancient peoples they displaced had been anonymously interred before them.

Almost 2 centuries after his ancestors settled in a bucolic paradise, Asa, a 1792 Yale graduate, elected to live and die in very different environs – the increasingly urban city of New Haven. Where in life he had achieved a certain stature as a member of a revered New England family, and respect as an eminent lawyer and teacher, so too in death would he enjoy social prominence. Having chosen the Elm City over Saybrook to live out his eternity, Chapman’s peace was to be found at the “New Burying Ground” (today’s Grove Street Cemetery), the first cemetery in the United States – and possibly the world – organized into privately-owned, well marked and articulated family lots.

snowy squash 159

Grove Street Cemetery was recognized as a National Historic Landmark in 2000 which goes to show that cultural landscapes matter just as much as buildings do for purposes of  interpreting our history (Photo Credit Jay Heritage Center)

This carefully delineated acreage, surrounded by wooden fencing, was laid out like a city map with names of avenues and addresses; it was not landscaped per se but it was shaded by graceful Lombardy spruce trees and syringa (lilac) shrubs. What it afforded families was a new and dignified alternative to the pell-mell disposal of bodies in colonial times. What few today realize is that this urban plan predates the more famous rural cemetery model of Mount Auburn in Boston by more than three decades. Created in 1796 following the pandemic hysteria of the yellow fever plagues, the cemetery was a refined advancement over the haphazard burials of bodies in unmarked graves on Town Greens throughout America. For example, rumored to hold the remains of over 5000 people (some of which were startlingly uprooted during Hurricane Sandy) New Haven’s Green belonged to all its citizens. As it had been established in the 1600s as an egalitarian communal square, it was as likely a destination for proper daylit processions of Puritans as it was for illicit midnight deposits of diseased corpses. The problem: So numerous and so shallow were the graves dug by New Haven’s mourners that the unearthing of random rib cages and femurs by humans and dogs alike was not uncommon. This fate was not to befall Asa Chapman or his contemporaries.

By comparison, the New Burying Ground was divided into an orderly grid: “One square for Yale College. One for strangers. One for people of color.” Chapman’s plot is marked by a red sandstone obelisk adjacent to the massive scrolled sarcophagus of his classmate, Eli Whitney, whose invention of the cotton gin in 1794 revolutionized American industry and makes him the cemetery’s most famous denizen. Whitney had died just 8 months before Chapman of prostate cancer. Having each secured verdant pallets on the same side of “Cedar Avenue,” classmates Chapman and Whitney shared prestigious real estate in their afterlives if not equal prestige in American memory. (One might gather that the Cedar Avenue address was especially choice as the famous lexicographer Noah Webster, also a Yale graduate, is buried in between Chapman and Whitney.)

That cachet could not have mattered much to Chapman’s surviving family. Extrapolating from the dates inscribed on the Chapman stone, William Chapman was only 12 years old when he lost his father. If the tragedy was devastating for William, it had to have been even more bewildering for his younger brother Henry, age 5. But they would survive and move forward vigorously with their lives as the next chapter will show.

snowy squash 170

Chapman obelisk (left) beside Webster monument (right) (Photo credit Jay Heritage Center)

Road Trips Along the King’s Highway

Mile Marker #24 in front of Jay photo circa 1905    

Above: Archival photo of Mile Marker 24 on Boston Post Road in front of the Jay Estate; Below: Aerial Photo of the BPR Historic District overlooking Long Island Sound (Photo Credit – Jay Heritage Center)

BPR from sky

Twenty years ago, in 1993the Boston Post Road (BPR) Historic District in Rye, New York was designated a National Historic Landmark (NHL) by the National Parks Service (NPS.)  What was it about this leafy green stretch of “The King’s Highway” that made it remarkable? Its physical features? Its natural beauty? Its stories? Or all of the above?

Recognition of this caliber is rare.  According to the National Parks Service website,  “National Historic Landmarks are exceptional places. They form a common bond between all Americans. While there are many historic places across the nation, only a small number have meaning to all Americans–these we call our National Historic Landmarks.”  

This blog came about as a way to help me better understand and explain three things 1) what constitutes an NHL (and differentiates it from the National Hockey League) 2) why was the 286 acre stretch of land in my own hometown “exceptional” and 3) how does this distinction actually help protect the places that we love?


Above: Bronze Plaque identifying the Boston Post Road (BPR) Historic District as a National Historic Landmark; Below: the Jay Estate today (Photo Credits – Jay Heritage Center)

view of mansion from under oldest horse chestnut

Having once spirited my family South for vacation, I knew that private passions for preserving timbers and wooden teeth had existed as early as the 19th century (i.e. The Mount Vernon Women’s Association that saved George Washington’s home in 1856.) I even knew about the Antiquities Act of 1906 which allows the President to protect public lands from development and create National Monuments — a prerogative that President Obama exercised just last week to protect the Harriet Tubman Home in Maryland, The San Juan Islands in Washington State and 3 other unique expanses in Delaware,  New Mexico, and Ohio. What I didn’t know was the detailed history that led the federal government to have an interest in helping to preserve the historic venues it didn’t own like the BPR Historic District or nearby Playland Amusement Park, another NHL in Rye designated in 1987.

playland 008              

Above: Bronze Plaque identifying Playland Amusement Park as a National Historic Landmark; Below: 1920s map of Playland “the first totally planned amusement park in America” (Photo Credit – Jay Heritage Center)

playland 003

When in doubt, go to the source. I went back to the NPS website and discovered a wonderful essay written in 1984 by Barry Mackintosh that read like a John Grisham novel. With subheadings titled “The Blair House Prototype” and “Mission 66” I was hooked. Who knew the preservation world held so much intrigue!

Though the National Parks Service was created in 1916,  its clear authority to survey and oversee the preservation of sites of  national  significance was a slow process as the charges of many agencies were consolidated under one body. It was not until the  Historic Sites Act of 1935 that preservation became active government policy. Similarly, the system of designating National Historic Landmarks didn’t happen overnight. Beloved places like the US CapitolMonticello, Bunker Hill, West PointMontpelier or the USS Constitution were not clearly designated National Historic Landmarks until 1960 and later.

It was the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 that further expanded the responsibilities of NPS to include state and local sites worthy of preservation though not necessarily of NHL stature. This was effected through the creation of a National Register list. Today there are over 80,000 buildings, parks, landscapes and archaeological sites in this inventory (and they have plaques too) but fewer than 2500 or 3% have been awarded NHL status.

Why is the bar so high? Because their intrinsic value must have meaning for all Americans, NHLs must satisfy strict criteria. They are selected because they fit in 1 or more categories – significant events in America’s history transpired at the site;  a prominent American figure lived or worked there;  an idea central to the shaping of our nation is embodied by the site; outstanding designs in architecture or spectacular landscapes, natural or man-made, can be seen and enjoyed;  invaluable archaeological deposits are preserved there;  or a distinctive way of life or cultural heritage is captured there. In future posts I will explain how the BPR Historic District was nominated and how it fits into every one of the aforementioned categories.

In other words, an NHL has staying power – it speaks to multiple generations and remains relevant. And if you have one in your backyard, it can be an amazing source of pride and merits some bragging.  Or blogging.